The High Court in Denu has quashed a ruling by the Anlo Traditional Council concerning the Dufia stool of Atorkor, ruling that the council did not have jurisdiction to determine the dispute.
Justice Sylvester Nii Okai Ablorh delivered the decision on Wednesday in the Volta Region. The judgment sets aside the ruling issued by the council’s judicial committee on 18 February in case ATC/13/2023.
The court’s order does not install or recognise a Dufia of Atorkor. It found that, although chieftaincy matters form part of Ghana’s constitutional system, a traditional council can hear a stool dispute only when it arises within its own traditional area.
The application was brought by Torgbi Dosu Adaku VIII of Atorkor, together with Samuel Ephraim Gemadzi, Dr Dennis Kofi Adaletey and Sylvanus Afetorgbor. The Anlo Traditional Council, based at Anloga, was named as the respondent.
The interested parties were Torgbi Ackumey Geli Adjorlolo III, Michael Jones Fenu and Courage Adjorlolo, all from Atorkor. Adjorlolo III had brought the original case claiming to be Dufia of Atorkor, alongside the other two parties, against Afetorgbor and Kwasi Besah.
The judicial committee sat at Anloga and relied on an earlier judgment delivered by the same council on 21 August 1987, which it considered binding on the Dosu Adaku side.
Its ruling stated: “the substantive Dufia of Atorkor as per the 21st August 1987 Judgment of the Judicial Committee of Anlo Traditional Council is Togbi Ackumey Geli Adjorlolo stool.”
That conclusion has now been overturned. A copy of the disputed decision, certified by the council’s registrar on 20 February, was submitted as part of the High Court proceedings.
The applicants argued that Atorkor falls within the Kome-Shime Traditional Area, which they said is distinct from Anlo and has its own traditional council and judicial committee.
They therefore challenged the authority of the panel that heard the case. It was chaired by Torgbi Samlafo IV of Avenor, with Torgbi Kpemini Gawu V of Whuti and Torgbi Hatsu III of Dzita. The applicants identify all three chiefs as belonging to Kome-Shime.
Section 29 of the Chieftaincy Act, 2008 (Act 759), gives a traditional council exclusive jurisdiction over a chieftaincy dispute arising within its area. Such a case must be heard by a judicial committee made up of three or five members of that council.
The motion, filed as suit C13/44/2026, was dated 15 May and lodged at Denu on 18 May. It was signed by E.A. Vordoagu of Vordoagu, Dzeble & Co.
In the original proceedings, the plaintiffs filed their motion on 14 December 2023, while the defence was submitted on 2 July 2024. The ruling challenged in the High Court was delivered on 18 February.
The applicants did not ask Justice Ablorh to select a Dufia. Their request was for the judicial committee’s ruling to be brought before the High Court and quashed, and that is the relief granted.
The case comes as the Ministry of Chieftaincy says it is seeking to revitalise the Chieftaincy Act and clarify lines of succession to reduce the number of stool disputes reaching the courts.
In the Eastern Nzema area, chiefs have also called on the government to intervene, saying disputes over stools there are threatening peace.